This beloved roadside spot on Olowalu Village Road between Lahaina and Maalaea is legendary for good reason — their banana cream pie will ruin you for all other banana cream pies. The balance is perfect: flaky, crunchy crust, fresh bananas, and whipped cream that doesn't go overboard on sweetness. The macadamia nut and coconut cream pies are equally phenomenal.
Beyond dessert, the savory game is strong too. The beef and potato pot pies are comfort food perfection, and that patty melt on fresh rye bread somehow manages to be both indulgent and surprisingly light. Chicken and waffles hit the sweet-savory balance just right. Expect a line out the door (especially at lunch), but service moves fast and you can order online ahead. Just know that popular pie flavors sell out by early afternoon, so don't wait until evening if dessert is your main goal.
💡 Insider Tip
Order online ahead to skip the inevitable line, and don't sleep on the patty melt — it's unexpectedly amazing. Popular pies sell out by mid-afternoon, so hit them early or call ahead for whole pies.
7 AM – 8 PM daily
$8–$16
Free lot
Lunch stop between Lahaina and Kihei
